Cake of the Month
Cake of the Month
Cake of the Month
Festive Cot M
cakes on a platter
  • Cake of the Month
  • Cake of the Month
  • Cake of the Month
  • Festive Cot M
  • cakes on a platter

Cake of the Month

regular price
sale price
regular price
Sold out
unit price label
translation missing: en.general.accessibility.unit_price_separator 


A holiday cake to make this year's celebrations a little sweeter!

December's cake, in collaboration with our friend & cookbook author Rebecca Firth, is a stunner. Spiced gingerbread cake layers and eggnog buttercream, topped off with candied cranberries and ginger cookie crumbs for extra sugar and spice!



Spiced Gingerbread & Eggnog Cake ships from December 19 - 21 ensuring delivery by Friday, December 23. 

For local pre-orders: order here

Cakes will stay fresh in the fridge for 5 days and in the freezer for up to 1 month. Be sure to bring cakes to room temperature before serving!


  • - Automatically places an order for each month’s cake
  • - Subscribers get 15% off online cookie orders, including local pre-order
  • - Option to update delivery address month-to-month. Feeling generous? Send to family, friends, and co-workers

  • Details
    • Each cake is 6” and serves 8-10 people.
    • Sample flavors include: Campfire Cake, Strawberry Basil ShortCake, Peppermint Patty Cake, Chocolate Banana Tahini Cake
    • The recipient of the cake will receive their first order the month following the purchase of the subscription or one time purchase (i.e if you place an order in June, your first cake will be the July cake).
    • Our cakes are perishable! It is very important that you or the recipient knows when to expect their package. Please read our FAQs for expected delivery dates.
    • Check out our terms of service here
  • Cake Club FAQS

    When will my cake ship out?

    All of our Cake of the Month orders will ship the fourth week of the month and you will receive shipping confirmations along with tracking numbers via email. Delivery dates are subject to change around the holiday season. 

    How do I store my cake once it arrives?

    When you receive the cake it can be stored in the refrigerator and then pulled out at least two hours prior to serving at room temperature. Just leave it on the counter, not in direct sunlight. Want to enjoy it later? Cakes can be frozen for up to 2 months and pulled out at least 8 hours in advance of serving.

    What if I’m not home when my cake is expected to arrive?

    Your cake can be left out in its shipping box for up to 24 hours (weather permitting!) If you will not be home the day your delivery is expected, we recommend asking a friend to store the cake for you. We cannot modify the monthly delivery dates.

    How do I cancel my subscription and can I get a refund for the cakes I didn’t yet receive?

    To cancel your subscription, please email We require 14 days notice from the delivery date for a full refund. We are unable to refund any cancelations made after the cut off date.

    Can I change the mailing address each month? 

    Yes! You can email with the updated address. All changes must be updated 14-days in advance of the delivery date. 

    Can I customize my subscription so that I receive cakes every other month?

    If you choose to subscribe, your subscription will be effective immediately and we are unable to mix and match months.

    How will I know what cake flavor I’m receiving?

    You will receive an email before your delivery with details about the cake of the month. Each Cake of the Month flavor features never-before-seen or tasted flavors.

    Can I substitute another flavor, customize my cake, or add writing?

    We do not offer customization or substitutions. You are able to add a gift note to your order on the product page.

    Do you offer corporate gifting?

    Yes! Send us an email at if you’d like to gift our Cake of the Month Club to more than 5 people.

    Can I add other treats to my subscription?

    You can make a separate purchase at

    Do you ship to Alaska or Hawaii?

    At this time we do not ship to Alaska or Hawaii.

  • Allergies & Dietary Restrictions

    We cannot accommodate substitutions for Cake of the Month Club and we do not list ingredients ahead of time. If you receive a cake and you have dietary restrictions or allergies, you can freeze the cake to bring to a celebration or share with others. We are not a nut-free or certified gluten-free bakery, but we take the utmost care in cleaning our equipment and keeping ingredients separate from one another. That said, if you have a severe allergy, we recommend not consuming our products.

  • Storage & Shipping Details

    This cake is made-to-order and promptly frozen. Although each box is carefully packed with ice packs and picked up for immediate shipment, it is normal for the cake and ice packs to partially or fully thaw during shipment. Upon receipt, please refrigerate or place in the freezer.

    This cake will stay fresh in the fridge for 5 days. If you wish to preserve your cake for longer, store it in the freezer for up to 1 month. Be sure to bring the cakes to room temperature before serving (remove cakes from the fridge 1-2 hours before serving).

    Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop. 

    Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.

Customer Reviews

Based on 55 reviews
Joanne Tuffy
Caramel Apple Pie

Awesome. I hope this cake is repeated. A true 5-star product.

anne m hamada
Chicago Thanksgiving Cake

We had a serious problem with what turned out to be a delicious Caramel/Apple Cake:
it arrived the day AFTER Thanksgiving😫
This was a big disappointment because it left me (the hostess who was so looking forward to it) with only one small dessert for 15 people on Thanksgiving😢 I don’t think Ovenly shipped it in time given how busy UPS & FED-
EX are in November and December.
Although the cake met my expectations in taste, I won’t be ordering from Ovenly again.
-anne h. in Chicago

Anne Wesp
Best in Sonoma!

I ordered this cake for Thanksgiving in Sonoma. It made it across the country in very good shape. And was delicious!

Suzanne Redpath

We loved the caramel apple pie cake.
Served it to family and guests and it was a hit.

Kirk Willoughby-Hudson
thanksgiving winner - caramel apple pie cake

the caramel apple pie cake was so good that it hardly survived thanksgiving. our guests quickly went back for seconds and the cake was finished in record time. the order and pick up process was also super simple.